Geno Smith will never win a big game in his NFL career after October 2, 2024.
First call: Oct 2, 2024, 10:32 AM ET · Deadline: Sep 24, 2026, 7:59 PM ET · Historical archive
“Having geno or darnold is a qb wasteland. Neither will ever win a big game”OPEN THE ORIGINAL POST ↗
What we’re scoring
Separate named player in the same neither assertion. Darnold evidence cannot grade Smith. Do not treat current absence of an established counterexample as proof of a lifetime negative; deadline is only a review checkpoint.
The ruling
Smith career is ongoing. No independently verified decisive post-source counterexample has been established in this review, and big game has no specified lower threshold.
View resolution evidence ↗Timeline & revisions
- Oct 2, 2024, 10:32 AM ET · originalGeno Smith will never win a big game in his NFL career after October 2, 2024.Source post ↗
Public review history (3)
- Sep 24, 2026, 5:47 PM ET · approve
Separate named player in the same neither assertion. Darnold evidence cannot grade Smith. Do not treat current absence of an established counterexample as proof of a lifetime negative; deadline is only a review checkpoint.
- Sep 24, 2026, 5:47 PM ET · verdict
Smith career is ongoing. No independently verified decisive post-source counterexample has been established in this review, and big game has no specified lower threshold.
- Sep 24, 2026, 5:49 PM ET · review-note
Separate named player in the same neither assertion. Darnold evidence cannot grade Smith. Do not treat current absence of an established counterexample as proof of a lifetime negative; deadline is only a review checkpoint. Jev advisory and original-source context manually reviewed; source-specific review decisions retained in the batch audit.
Something doesn’t add up?
Send a factual correction with evidence. It goes to the review queue; it never changes the record automatically. Please leave out personal information.